Difference between revisions of "Bibliography: Mill power draw models"
(→Nordberg Model for Ball Mills) |
(→Nordberg Model for SAG; J. Starkey et al) |
||
| (10 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
== Mill Power Draw Model Bibliography == |
== Mill Power Draw Model Bibliography == |
||
| − | Mill power draw models are used to predict the usable power draw that a particular mill will generate. |
+ | Mill power draw models are used to predict the usable power draw that a particular mill will generate. The three SAG mill models are benchmarked and reviewed in: |
| + | |||
| + | # ''Doll, A.G.'', '''A comparison of SAG mill power models''', <i>Procemin 2013</i> [https://www.sagmilling.com/articles/20/view/?s=1] |
||
=== Austin SAG Model === |
=== Austin SAG Model === |
||
| Line 8: | Line 10: | ||
The Austin SAG model was published in: |
The Austin SAG model was published in: |
||
| − | # ''Austin, L.G.'', '''A mill power equation for SAG mills''', <i>Minerals & Metallurgical Processing;</i> Society for Mining, Metallurgy & Exploration, February 1990. [http://www.onemine.org/ |
+ | # ''Austin, L.G.'', '''A mill power equation for SAG mills''', <i>Minerals & Metallurgical Processing;</i> Society for Mining, Metallurgy & Exploration, February 1990. [http://www.onemine.org/document/abstract.cfm?docid=4603&title=A-mill-power-equation-for-SAG-mills] |
=== Morrell Models === |
=== Morrell Models === |
||
| Line 14: | Line 16: | ||
The Morrell models for SAG and ball milling are all derived from the same reference and differ in some default parameter values and in the geometry of the mill charge (grate versus overflow discharge). |
The Morrell models for SAG and ball milling are all derived from the same reference and differ in some default parameter values and in the geometry of the mill charge (grate versus overflow discharge). |
||
| − | # ''Napier-Munn, T.J.; Morrell, S.; Morrison, R.D.; Kojovic, T.'', '''Mineral Comminution Circuits; Their Operation and Optimisation'''; <i>Julius Kruttschnitt Mineral Research Centre,</i> Indooroopilly, Queensland, Australia. First ed. 1996, republished 1999 & 2005. [http://www.jkmrc.uq.edu.au/ |
+ | # ''Napier-Munn, T.J.; Morrell, S.; Morrison, R.D.; Kojovic, T.'', '''Mineral Comminution Circuits; Their Operation and Optimisation'''; <i>Julius Kruttschnitt Mineral Research Centre,</i> Indooroopilly, Queensland, Australia. First ed. 1996, republished 1999 & 2005. [http://www.jkmrc.uq.edu.au/jkmrc-mineral-comminution-circuits] |
=== Loveday/Barratt Model === |
=== Loveday/Barratt Model === |
||
| − | Loveday produced a largely empirical model using a "Power Number" parameter |
+ | Loveday produced a largely empirical model using a "Power Number" parameter: |
| + | # ''Loveday, B.K.'', '''Prediction of autogenous milling from pilot-plant tests''', Proceedings of the Eleventh Commonwealth Mining and Metallurgical Congress, Hong Kong, 1978, Pages 557-564 |
||
| + | Barratt developed a chart of "Power Numbers" for SAG mills that was published in: |
||
# ''Barratt, D.J. & Sherman, M'', '''Selection and Sizing of Autogenous and Semi-Autogenous Mills''', Mineral Processing Plant Design, Practice, and Control. Society for Mining , Metallurgy & Exploration (SME), 2002, Pages 755-782. |
# ''Barratt, D.J. & Sherman, M'', '''Selection and Sizing of Autogenous and Semi-Autogenous Mills''', Mineral Processing Plant Design, Practice, and Control. Society for Mining , Metallurgy & Exploration (SME), 2002, Pages 755-782. |
||
=== Nordberg Model for Ball Mills === |
=== Nordberg Model for Ball Mills === |
||
| − | # ''Rexnord Corporation'', '''Nordberg |
+ | # ''Rexnord Corporation'', '''Nordberg Red Book''', third edition, section 17 |
| + | # ''Outokumpu Mills Group'', '''The Science of Comminution''', (2002) technical publication P. 39 |
||
=== Nordberg Model for SAG; J. Starkey et al === |
=== Nordberg Model for SAG; J. Starkey et al === |
||
| + | (not implemented as a SAG model, but some concepts included in the Nordberg ball mill model) |
||
| − | |||
# ''Starkey, J.; Hindstrom, S. & Orser, T.'' '''Choosing a SAG Mill To Achieve Design Performance'''; AGM of Canadian Mineral Processors, 2003. Pages 305-316 |
# ''Starkey, J.; Hindstrom, S. & Orser, T.'' '''Choosing a SAG Mill To Achieve Design Performance'''; AGM of Canadian Mineral Processors, 2003. Pages 305-316 |
||
# ''Starkey, J.'' '''Impact on Grinding Mill Design of Recent New Discoveries'''; Society for Mining , Metallurgy & Exploration (SME), 2009, Pages 340-346 |
# ''Starkey, J.'' '''Impact on Grinding Mill Design of Recent New Discoveries'''; Society for Mining , Metallurgy & Exploration (SME), 2009, Pages 340-346 |
||
| + | === Other useful papers === |
||
| + | # ''Barratt, D.J. & Brodie, M.N.'' '''The "Tent" Diagram, What It Means'''; Proceedings of the SAG 2001 Conference, Vancouver, Canada, Pages IV-368 to IV-39. |
||
Latest revision as of 20:51, 1 March 2019
Contents
Mill Power Draw Model Bibliography
Mill power draw models are used to predict the usable power draw that a particular mill will generate. The three SAG mill models are benchmarked and reviewed in:
- Doll, A.G., A comparison of SAG mill power models, Procemin 2013 [1]
Austin SAG Model
The Austin SAG model was published in:
- Austin, L.G., A mill power equation for SAG mills, Minerals & Metallurgical Processing; Society for Mining, Metallurgy & Exploration, February 1990. [2]
Morrell Models
The Morrell models for SAG and ball milling are all derived from the same reference and differ in some default parameter values and in the geometry of the mill charge (grate versus overflow discharge).
- Napier-Munn, T.J.; Morrell, S.; Morrison, R.D.; Kojovic, T., Mineral Comminution Circuits; Their Operation and Optimisation; Julius Kruttschnitt Mineral Research Centre, Indooroopilly, Queensland, Australia. First ed. 1996, republished 1999 & 2005. [3]
Loveday/Barratt Model
Loveday produced a largely empirical model using a "Power Number" parameter:
- Loveday, B.K., Prediction of autogenous milling from pilot-plant tests, Proceedings of the Eleventh Commonwealth Mining and Metallurgical Congress, Hong Kong, 1978, Pages 557-564
Barratt developed a chart of "Power Numbers" for SAG mills that was published in:
- Barratt, D.J. & Sherman, M, Selection and Sizing of Autogenous and Semi-Autogenous Mills, Mineral Processing Plant Design, Practice, and Control. Society for Mining , Metallurgy & Exploration (SME), 2002, Pages 755-782.
Nordberg Model for Ball Mills
- Rexnord Corporation, Nordberg Red Book, third edition, section 17
- Outokumpu Mills Group, The Science of Comminution, (2002) technical publication P. 39
Nordberg Model for SAG; J. Starkey et al
(not implemented as a SAG model, but some concepts included in the Nordberg ball mill model)
- Starkey, J.; Hindstrom, S. & Orser, T. Choosing a SAG Mill To Achieve Design Performance; AGM of Canadian Mineral Processors, 2003. Pages 305-316
- Starkey, J. Impact on Grinding Mill Design of Recent New Discoveries; Society for Mining , Metallurgy & Exploration (SME), 2009, Pages 340-346
Other useful papers
- Barratt, D.J. & Brodie, M.N. The "Tent" Diagram, What It Means; Proceedings of the SAG 2001 Conference, Vancouver, Canada, Pages IV-368 to IV-39.
